andi11
Member

****
zweite single der jungs. nicht so eingängig wie die erste, dafür auch keine kopie davon.
und nach 2-3 mal hören bleibt der song dann doch hängen im ohr...

Der_Nagel
Member

**
schwache Boygroup-Nummer mit nervigem Chorus – 2*…

Miraculi
Member

****
Warum leiern die Boygroups immer so 90s like? Der Chorus ist fluffig-poppig geworden - und der kann halbwegs überzeugen.

nirvanamusic87
Member

***
This isn't great quite boring and not particularily memorable. A weak follow up to a high spirited debut. 2nd UK top 10. 7 weeks in the UK top 100. UK#3 and Ireland#3. 119,600 copies sold in the UK.
Last edited: 13/05/2012 17:36

Mykl_77
Member

**
Totally agree. With such high hopes after the ultra-catchy What Makes You Beautiful, this is a very poor follow up. Just really boring. I know it's a ballad, but there's no heart in it.

artistry
Member

******
Disappointing follow-up to the mega-awesome What Makes You Beautiful. I know they're doing the tried and tested second single ballad, but surely with all the songs out there, they could've found something more memorable?

Edit: Okay, on more listens, I can't get enough of this song. I love One Direction so much!
Last edited: 13/12/2011 02:27

Chemmical
Member

**
Agree with the comments above. This is a poor attempt at a ballad just like Heart Vacancy was for The Wanted.

Musicfreaky_93
Member

**
Und es heulen die Werwölfe im Wald..

bluezombie
Member

****
I'd hoped for something better, but as a standalone song, it's not that bad. The chorus is nothing special, but the verses are quite decent. 3.5

King Peos
Member

**
Seichte Ballade mit schmierigem Boyband-Gesang und unglaublich flacher Melodieführung. Knappe 2*

KitchenTel
Member

***
Ouch !

Chris A
Member

***
Decent song.

bsb745
Member

******
I really enjoy it, I cant get enough of this band.

Roger Hürlimann
Member

*
Klingt als hätte man ihnen in die Eier geschlagen, als sie den Aufnahmen. Ganz schlimmes gesäusel!

fudge911
Member

****
The song is alright itself, but the chorus is a let down and sorta annoying.

Starbuck
Member

****
Sehr schöner song!

BeansterBarnes
Member

****
It's a step in the right direction as that booming chorus is pretty spectacular.

antonnalan
Member

*****
Strong ballad that although doesn't match to One Thing or What Makes You Beautiful, it stands as a good contrast to the two. The chorus is highlighted very well.

EDIT: I now think it is just as good as What Makes You Beautiful, but One Thing will always be their best.
Last edited: 02/09/2012 08:20

TheIncrediblePlumber
Member

***
I preferred this to What Makes You Beautiful, but then again, I hated WMYB and I loathe One Direction.

sophieellisbextor
Staff

****
Je préfère les autres singles de "Up All Night".

Kamala
Member

**
... ach wie süüüss...

Getharda
Member

***
Belanglose Nummer, klare 3*.

musikmannen
Member

*
Awful song, by a awful group

irelander
Member

**
I didn't hate it too much but it's so full of soppy cliches. At least it's more boring than it is annoying.

Hijinx
Member

***
The music is nice but I can't help but feel that it's missing something. Just feels a little empty I think.

SoC_Girl
Member

**
Schmachteboygroupsongs... nein danke!

ul.tra
Member

**
Nein, danke...

Fabio (auch Fabi GaGa)
Member

****
nicht ihr bestes stück...eine der schwächeren sigles auf dem sonst sehr guten album "Up all night"

schnurridiburr
Member

**
Haha, nein.

liam99
Member

*
Terrible. Definitely a 1 for me .

392414
Member

***
Possibly the weakest song on the album, but it's still not bad.

ShadowViolin
Member

***
Schwacher Song von den Jungs, zurecht kein Erfolg.

-3*

fabio
Member

**
2-3

southpaw
Member

***
14 Jahre alt und weiblich müsste man sein.

Werner
Member

***
...southpaw, es reicht auch schon zwölf...

Zacco333
Member

**
Very boring song