remix1970
Member

*****
Sehr schöne House Nummer.

Der_Nagel
Member

***
Hier gibt es ein Mash-Up von The Boy Is Mine (Brandy & Monica) sowie Girl (Destiny's Child) auf die Ohren, 2.75…

HASE22
Member

****
ganz nette Housenummer - solide 4

TravD
Member

****
Another '90s track revived by a random dance act in the '10s, but similar to 'Bump & Grind 2014', this somehow works wonders after a few listens. Definitely growing on me at the moment.
Last edited: 23/11/2015 11:39

southpaw
Member

****
Mit feinen Zutaten bestückt und leidlich schmackhaft gebacken.

rotrigodelafuente
Member

****
gut produziertes und durchaus nettes house-remake der beiden cont. r'n'b-nummern

Chartsfohlen
Member

****
Danke für die Info, dass es sich hierbei um ein Mash-Up bereits zuvor veröffentlichter Song handelt - hatte mich schon gewundert, dass es Neues von Destiny's Child geben soll. Joar, ist alles in allem ganz ordentlich und hörbar gestaltet, ohne herauszuragen.<br><br>Eher knappe 4.

Kamala
Member

***
...ich mag diesen Misch-"Mash" nicht - Kälte aussendender Titel -...

Reto
Member

******
Genialer Sound.

gherkin
Member

***
Best wel aardig gedaan.

Snormobiel Beusichem
Member

*****
▒ Goed plaatje en leuke samenwerking uit begin lente 2015 (Holland) !!! Bevalt mij uitstekend !!! Vandaar ook 5 sterren ☺!!!

Cheetah
Member

****
Prima

sirvmr
Member

****
As TravD said, the charts have been awash with dance remakes of old tracks in the past couple of years (e.g. "The Party (This Is How We Do It)", "Easy Love", "Nobody To Love", and "Bump N Grind 2014") and all of them have the same appeal. "The Girl Is Mine" is no different. It's enjoyable with a nice enough beat. Won't go down in history, but will be good to hear in a club and it's always nice to hear old tracks you used to love getting a go again. I especially like the "can I please talk to you for a minute" section borrowed from "The Boy Is Mine".<br><br>Apparently this track was ready for release in 2014, but Monica wouldn't clear the sample. May explain why her vocal contribution to "The Boy Is Mine" is not included.

savagegrant
Member

****
The charts have not been awash with dance remakes of old tracks in the past couple of years. There's been a few lately whereas there was next to none in the early 2010s, which may give the impression of some kind of awashment but real awashment was in the mid to late 2000s. :P

LIFTER500
Member

***
Average.

bluezombie
Member

**
Girl was already a terrible song, so I guess congratulations are in order for finding a way to make it sound worse. Good on Monica for declining any part in this, much respect. This is annoying and stupid.

jayj95
Member

**
They should of left one of the greatest duets of all time alone TBH. It just doesn’t sound right with just Brandy on vocals and Beyoncé going over the top.
Last edited: 02/12/2021 12:17

silvm
Member

****
Ok

ul.tra
Member

****
Das klingt schwach. Geht aber auf der Tanzfläche gut. *4-

irelander
Member

***
The beat is ok but otherwise not for me.

alleyt1989
Member

*
Not good at all. Hard to listen to right through. The more I think about this song the more it pisses me off. Down to a 1 now.
Last edited: 30/12/2015 08:23

sophieellisbextor
Staff

****
Un mash-up house plutôt sympa !

Besnik
Member

****
Dieses Mashup finde ich eigentlich ziemlich gelungen, hat einen ganz coolen Groove! Auf jeden Fall besser als vieles was sich gerade so in den Charts befindet!

Werner
Member

***
...solide drei...

emalovic
Member

*
Gähn langweilig....<br><br>einige Mashups sind ja klasse. Allerdings ist dies überflüssig wie Scheisse...

oldiefan1
Member

***
eine ordentliche 3

Widmann1
Member

****
Wie schon von andere erwähnt eine House-Nummer und somit anders als die sonstigen Titel. Höchstwertung für Destiny's Child bei mir.

Pottkind
Member

*****
Hier wurde aus zwei halbguten Songs ein richtig gutes neues Produkt erstellt, welches die beiden RnB-Nummern auf eine neue Ebene packt, sodass man die alten Versionen gar nicht mehr hören will.<br>99 Souls haben es einach drauf, ich glaube von denen werden wir noch viel hören.

BeansterBarnes
Member

****
Peaked at #9 on my personal chart.<br><br><br>P = 42
Last edited: 13/05/2024 02:58

tgebele
Member

****
Ich finde diese Nummer nicht schlecht. Interessantes Mash-up der beiden schon mehrfach angesprochenen Titel.

Roefe
Member

*****
Guter Mix.

Songlove
Member

******
♡

clublover
Member

***
Da gibt es bedeutend besseres.

da_hooliii
Member

***
Dieser Clubsong sorgt nicht wirklich für Stimmung.

Chuck_P
Member

****
gelungener dance-pop-song.

scheibi
Member

***
gerade noch erträglich