***** i agree the visual was brilliant and the choreography was so fitting - it reminded me of the actual umbrella. i don't think the songs fit together so well though imo
EDIT: Are we professional reviewers? Because I believe songs can be rated however we want. If a video changes our perception of a song, then we have a duty to include this as a reason for why we've given the song a high rating. All subjective of course. Last edited: 16/05/2011 10:10
* feat. Gwyneth Paltrow - merkwürdig, dass das noch niemand erwähnt hat - ein Nervtöter sondergleichen - Umbrella will ich also die nächsten 10 Jahre sicherlich nicht mehr hören, derart dauerbeschallt ist man damit geworden - Nagel!...derzeitige Platzierungen: #10 in IRL, #18 in den Billboard Hot 100, #20 CAN, #23 AUS...
** Seriously dated production and just generally poorly arranged. As someone who once thought that 'eh, eh, eh' was the most ridiculous thing ever and made me seriously question how anyone could enjoy a song like that...I surely never thought it was as bad as whatever they're doing here! 1.8 Last edited: 30/01/2014 02:37
* Look have we here? A song that is only good because of the video?
I agree that the video/choreography is interesting but this is a song thank you very much! Umbrella and Singin' In The Rain simply don't go together musically and songs shouldn't be rated by the 'interesting-ness' of the video!
***** One of my favourite mashups from the Glee gang. The inclusion of Singin' In The Rain helps improve the dreadful Rihanna arrangement of Umbrella. Matthew's vocals are great and Gwyneth's aren't as whiny as usual.
****** Finde das auch wieder einen total geilen Mash Up! Ich finde die Songs passen zusammen, also auf jeden Fall so wie sie sie hier zusammen gemischt haben! :) Gwyneth Paltrow ist schon nicht die beste Sängerin, das hört man hier, aber geil ist es trotzdem!